Skip to content


Your cart is empty

Article: Jon Ostrander's Croque Reuben Toastie


Jon Ostrander's Croque Reuben Toastie

What You Need:

- 1 Tbps. Kewpie mayo

- 1 Tsp dijon mustard

- 1 Tsp Woodsman prepared horseradish

- 1 Tsp confirm shallots (or caramelized onions)

 Who Created It:

Jon Ostrander 

10 years ago, Jon "Sandwich Dad" Ostrander started making a giant sandwich every year on his birthday instead of a birthday cake. Every year the sandwiches grew more and more elaborate and required more research and planning, turning him into an accidental sandwich scholar along the way. He began writing about sandwiches on a little WordPress blog, and gained his nickname as well as some small renown around his home in Whitehorse Yukon. Not long after that he began posting and narrating his sandwich making on TikTok, where he's well know as an integral part of #sandwichtok. 

How To Make It:

This take on the classic reuben sandwich is a little saucier, tastier, and a little more French! Nothing better than meat, cheese, pickles, and a yummy sauce between nicely toasted bread. This toastie tastes just as professional as it looks.


  • Grab your bread and spread the sauce on both sides of it. Place 3 slices of cheese on each side of the bread. Place 3 slices of ham on one piece of bread. Julien 1 dill pickle and place on the other side from the ham. 


  • Put the sandwich together and place in the Revolution Toastie Press.
  • Place the Toastie Press in your toaster and select your desired done-ness.
  • Let it cool for 1 minute, the slice diagonally and enjoy!

Have you made the Croquet Reuben Toastie with your Revolution Toastie Press? Post a photo on Instagram and tag @RevCooking!

Introducing the Revolution Toastie Press

Because big appliances are a big pain.

We’re going to assume we don’t need to sell you on the idea of a panini. Who doesn’t love the melty-deliciousness of a pressed sandwich, right? But big appliances are, well, a big pain. You need to lug them out, they can be hard to clean and they take up valuable counter space. This Toastie Press attachment is our solution: Simple, compact and super easy to use it gives you the sandwiches you love, minus the mess and hassle you don’t.

  • Heats up quickly: Deliver the toastie of your dreams in seconds not minutes. (Learn more about our safe, eco-friendly InstaGLO technology here!)
  • Easy to clean: Wipe down with a sponge or pop it in the dishwasher.
  • Small footprint: Stash it with your coffee, in your bread box or just sit it in the toaster when not in use.

Faster. Smarter. Tastier.
Shop now.

More News + Recipes


Spritzes and Sandwiches

Round 1: Aperol Spritz & Mozzarella, Pepper, and Arugula Panini By: Tomlin Cicci Grab your Revolution Toaster (or any toaster) and your Toastie Press! Trader Joe's haul! All the ingredients I...

Read more
gluten free

Going Against the Grain: a Gluten-Free Blog

Ever wonder about the R270's Gluten-Free mode? Introducing Revolution Cooking's R270 Toaster: Created with 34 bread types, a personalized home menu, modes for both accessories, and a new gluten-fre...

Read more