Skip to content


Your cart is empty

Article: The G.O.A.T: Goat Cheese, Fig Jam, Caramelized Onion, & Arugula Grilled Cheese

The G.O.A.T: Goat Cheese, Fig Jam, Caramelized Onion, & Arugula Grilled Cheese

The G.O.A.T: Goat Cheese, Fig Jam, Caramelized Onion, & Arugula Grilled Cheese

 Active time: 10 min Cook time: 6 min Serves: 1

This isn't your kid's grilled cheese.

We are changing the way you think about your favorite toasted classic! Introducing, The G.O.A.T..The Greatest of All Time. Your initial thought might not be to use goat cheese as the main cheese source in a grilled cheese sandwich, but we are here to prove you wrong!

The richness of the goat cheese, mixed with the peppery arugula, sweet fig jam, and savory-sweetness of the caramelized onion is bound to make this a regular staple in your home.  



  • 2 slices of your bread of choice (we like Country White for this one)
  • 2 Tbsp. fig jam
  • 2 oz. goat cheese
  • 1 oz. arugula 
  • 1/2 white onion, sliced
  • 1 tsp. softened butter (optional)



  • Melt some butter over medium heat in a skillet.
  • Add your thinly chopped onion and cook until brown and tender.
  • Take off the heat and set to the side.


  • Spread a thin layer of jam on each slice of bread.
  • On the first slice add the goat cheese, arugula, and caramelized onion.
  • Now close it up with the other piece of bread, jam side down. See how easy that was? 
two pieces of bread. on one slice there is fig jam and arugula and on the other there is caramelized onion and goat cheese


  • Now place it in the Toastie Press and close and lock the press. Wipe around the outside of the press to clean off any drips with a paper towel. 
  • Place the filled Toastie Press into the right slot of your Revolution Toaster with the handles facing out.

Now make your next selection based on the model you have:

Image explaining how to use the toastie press properly. If you have the Revolution InstaGLO® R270  Toaster you can add the Panini Mode directly to your home menu in settings. On your home menu, select Panini Select level of toastyness  Press "start". If you have the Revolution InstaGLO® R180S or R180B, go to the Bread mode on your home menu, and look for the "Panini Mode" toggle at the bottom left. Toggle Panini Mode ON Select your level of toastyness Press "start"
    toasted sandwich in an open toastie press
    LOVE IT.
      • Serve with chips or a side salad and enjoy!

      The G.O.A.T: Goat Cheese, Fig Jam, Caramelized Onion, & Arugula Grilled Cheese


      Have you made the The G.O.A.T in your Revolution InstaGLO® Toaster with Revolution Toastie Press? Post a photo on Instagram and tag @RevCooking!

      Introducing the Revolution Toastie Press

      Because big appliances are a big pain.

      We’re going to assume we don’t need to sell you on the idea of a toastie. Who doesn’t love the melty-deliciousness of a pressed sandwich, right? But big appliances are, well, a big pain. You need to lug them out, they can be hard to clean and they take up valuable counter space. This toastie attachment is our solution: Simple, compact and super easy to use it gives you the sandwiches you love, minus the mess and hassle you don’t.

      • Heats up quickly: Deliver the toastie of your dreams in seconds not minutes. (Learn more about our safe, eco-friendly InstaGLO technology here!)
      • Easy to clean: Wipe down with a sponge or pop it in the dishwasher.
      • Small footprint: Stash it with your coffee, in your bread box or just sit it in the toaster when not in use.

      Faster. Smarter. Tastier.
      Shop now.

      More News + Recipes

      Toaster grilled cheese in toastie press

      How to make a Grilled Cheese with your Revolution Toaster & Panini Press

      We've already revolutionized the toaster; up next, everyone's favorite comfort classic, the GRILLED CHEESE. Say goodbye to clunky pans and spatulas, and hello to delicious grilled cheese faster an...

      Read more
      Revolution Toastie Press open on the counter with a toasted Triangle fold quesadilla inside. limes and salsa next to it

      How To Make a Toasterdilla: Triangle Fold Method

      We've dreamt of this day for as long as we can remember! A day when a quesadilla becomes a "grab and go" kind of food. Thanks to the Revolution Panini Press accessory, that dream has become a reali...

      Read more